ITC ruled that Motorola did not infringe Apple multi-touch patent

According to media reports , the U.S. International Trade Commission ( International Trade Commission, ITC ) ruled on Friday that Motorola's Dr Dre Beats mobile did not infringe Apple multi-touch patent . In October 2010 , Apple sued Motorola mobile Droid , Droid 2 , Droid X , Cliq, BackFlip , Devour , Charm and other smart phones , and Xoom Tablet PC violated Apple's multi-touch patented technology . Theodore - Essex ( Theodore of Essex ) , ITC judge had initially ruled that Apple lost the case , but since Apple has filed an appeal . ITC on Friday said that the Commission carefully reviewed the judgments Dre Beats made ​​by Essex , and decided to re-examine part of the judgment . The final full survey results will be announced later . Apple and Motorola Mobile representatives were not immediately respond to media requests for interviews , telephone. According to statistics released by market research firm Gartner , in 2012 global sales of tablet PCs Soccer Jerseys is expected to reach 103.5 million units , while sales of the Apple iPad it is estimated that two - thirds of the total sales . Motorola Mobile Apple alleged violations of the company's patent litigation brought to the ITC . ITC Judge Thomas - Pender ( Thomas, the Pender ) plans will be announced on April 23 this year, the verdict in this case .